Serve From Overflow, Not Exhaustion

How to Get Spiritually Unstuck and Safeguard Your Mental Health

Sybil Kearse

5/22/20252 min read

The Weight We Carry


If you’ve been shouldering ministry or leadership responsibilities for any length of time, you already know how quietly burnout creeps in. Recent surveys show that more than 40 percent of U.S. pastors have considered leaving their congregations since 2020, citing collective trauma, dwindling attendance, and conflict fatigue as prime stressors.AP News Other studies estimate that one in five clergy now score within the clinical-depression range on standard wellness scales, outpacing the general population.Anglican Futures

Yet Scripture paints a different picture for our souls: “Come to Me, all you who labor and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest” (Matthew 11:28). The tension between Christ’s invitation and our lived experience begs a deeper question: How do we move from empty to overflow—practically and spiritually?

Spirituality Meets Mental Health

Psychologists continue to confirm what believers have long intuited: robust spiritual practices reduce anxiety, buffer depression, and bolster resilience.Psychology TodayMcLean Hospital One meta-analysis even links regular faith engagement with measurably lower stress hormones and stronger immune response.PMC But data also reveal a sobering flip side—91 percent of ministry leaders admit to some form of burnout, and nearly one in five describe themselves as “fried to a crisp right now.”Soul Shepherding

Spiritual disciplines clearly matter, yet they are not automatic shields against emotional overload. That is where spiritually informed mental-health coaching steps in, offering a bridge between prayer and practical symptom management so you can serve from a place of abundance, not depletion.

Five Warning Signs You May Be Spiritually Stuck
  1. Chronic Soul Fatigue —You wake up tired even after sleep, and spiritual practices feel like chores instead of lifelines.

  2. Rumination Loops —Your mind rehearses the same conflicts, regrets, or “should-haves,” drowning out God’s voice (see Psalm 42:5).

  3. Compassion Collapse —Empathy once flowed freely, but now you feel numb or irritable toward the very people you’re called to love (Galatians 6:9).

  4. Performance Over Presence —You prepare sermons or strategy decks with excellence yet struggle to enjoy unhurried time with Jesus (John 15:4).

  5. Isolation in Success or Suffering —Whether things go well or poorly, you default to lone-wolf mode instead of healthy interdependence (Ecclesiastes 4:9-10).

If any of these resonate, take heart: awareness is the first pivot point toward freedom.

Three Moves Toward Overflow

Renew the Mind
Neuroscience shows that reflective prayer, Scripture meditation, and gratitude practice rewire stress pathways, lowering cortisol and enhancing emotional regulation. Pair Romans 12:2 transformation with evidence-based techniques—such as breath prayer and cognitive reframing—to quiet anxious loops.

Rebuild Rhythms
Jesus modeled cycles of intense ministry followed by intentional withdrawal (Mark 1:35; 6:31). Schedule Sabbath blocks, micro-retreats, and tech-free evenings like non-negotiable meetings with God. Symptom trackers or mood journals can alert you when rhythms drift.

Reach for Collaborative Care
A spiritually informed coach helps you integrate biblical truth with tools like grounding exercises, resilience mapping, and boundary setting. When deeper clinical issues surface—trauma, addiction, suicidal ideation—ethical coaching mandates swift referral to licensed therapists or psychiatrists. In a holistic ecosystem, prayer and professional care are partners, not rivals.

Ready to Break Free?

I’ve distilled these insights into a concise, actionable resource titled “5 Signs You’re Spiritually Stuck (and How to Move Forward).” Download it free today and receive an exclusive invitation to my upcoming live masterclass, “Unleashed & Loosed for Greater Purpose,” where we’ll dig deeper into restoring overflow.

Download the guide and reserve your seat at fbmla.org/free-masterclass

Because your calling matters—and so does your well-being. Let’s journey from stuck to soaring, together.